Critique Clearinghouse

The Critique Clearinghouse offers GVC members an opportunity to submit work to a published author for objective feedback. The service is free and anonymous on both sides.

FAQ's

Q: Who uses the service?

A: Any member in good standing with GVC. Most often we see new members who haven't made contacts or formed a critique group of their own. Sometimes our more advanced writers have worked through their critique group's suggestions and would like a fresh view of their project before they submit to an editor.

Q: How much can I submit?

A: As much as you like, from query letter to complete manuscript. Keep in mind, however, that our published authors are working writers. Finding one available to read a full manuscript may mean a long wait. On the other hand, if you submit opening chapters and the author sees potential, she may offer to read the rest.

Q: How often can I submit?

A: We have a limited number of published authors so, as a rule of thumb, one submission annually. However, if you previously submitted a partial and now have something short, like a query letter, we'll try to accommodate.

Q: Who looks at my work?

A: We try to match your work with a published author writing in your market, i.e. historical, sweet, sexy, etc.

Q: What kind of feedback can I expect?

A: You specify your needs when you submit, from marketing advice to a line edit. Keep in mind our published authors are volunteers. If you are looking for a detailed critique including grammar and style, you ought to keep your submission to something short such as a query letter or 2-3 page synopsis. Generally you can expect to receive tips on strengthening basic storytelling elements such as plot, character, sexual tension, etc.

Q: What if I don't agree with the opinion I'm given?

A: Our published authors base their suggestions on their own experience. They are not grading your work or guaranteeing publication. Part of becoming a writer is learning to separate yourself from your work and from other people's opinions of your work. You must decide what feels right and disregard the rest.

Q: How long does it take?

A: The search begins as soon as you contact the coordinator. After that, it depends on the author's time table and the length of the submission.

Q: Why anonymous?

A: Submitting your work for the first time is a brave act. Sometimes it is easier to do it without your name attached. You and/or the published author may choose to contact each other directly but should either of you wish to maintain your privacy, the system is set up to do that.

Q: Is it really free?

A: Unless postage is necessary, it is absolutely free.

"It's a terrific service to members. I only hope to help someone in turn someday."

- Connie Gibbs, GVC member and Critique Clearinghouse customer