HOMEMEMBERSPUBLISHED AUTHORSMEETINGS
EVENTSNEWSLIBRARYNEWSLETTERLINKS
 

March 2004 Spotlight Featured Article

Salvaging the Rejection-Scarred Muse

I have been training to be a writer most of my life. A rejected writer, that is. While I was growing up, like most children, I tried on many different hats trying to discover what fit and who I would become. As I grew older, many of my original hopes and dreams were rejected and discarded.

For example, when I was two years old I wanted to be a pony. I did not want to have a pony. I wanted to be one. I was convinced that if I ate all my veggies and didn’t pick my nose during church, my wish would come true. It didn’t.

Then when I was three I decided I would be a princess when I grew up. I found out that royalty was something you had to be born into and that there was more to it then just remembering to wear your knickers whenever you wore a really short party dress. Being a princess was rejected and I stopped practicing my royal wave.

At six I really wanted to be a fireman. My older sister told me there was no way I could be a fireman because everyone knew that firemen were boys. She also said that using dad’s razor would only scar me for life and not turn me into a boy. So I put away the razor and went on to elementary school where I learned that when you stick your tongue out at the class bully, he’ll probably slug you.

When I was 12 years old I read my first romance novel and I was blown away. Wow! I thought, I can do this. I sat down and wrote the most poignant, gloomy pages ever written, filled with pre-teen angst. As I wrote, I had tears streaming down my face because I was just so moved by my dramatic scene. I was so excited when a relative read my work. I thought, Ah Hah! I’ve found my calling! I’ll be a writer. Then my relative laughed and said that I’d never be a writer because I had no gift for words.

Of course, for the next 20 years I did nothing but prove her right. It’s amazing how we can take to heart the insults and criticisms of others and cherish them inside ourselves, allowing those words to define who we are and what we will become.

When I graduated from high school I had absolutely no idea what I would do with the rest of my life. My mother said I should go to secretarial school because there was always a need for good secretaries. So I went off and studied Pitman shorthand. Now, twenty-four years later, I have yet to find a use for this skill.

I believe that each and every one of us receives gifts that help us along our journey in life. The problem is that often these gifts are disguised as problems, or obstacles. Having a pile of kids, for example, although truly a gift, can also be an obstacle when trying to write.

When I was thirty-four years old I woke up one rainy, miserable morning with three whining children velcroed to my ankles. I screamed, “If I don’t do something using my mind, I’m going to lose it!”

My husband, in his wisest and most patient voice, told me that I should write a book. He said, “You’re a great mother. You should write a children’s book, or a motivational book for parents.”

Taking part of his advice, I sat down and wrote a murder scene where a wise and patient husband had an incredibly gory death.

However, my husband’s suggestion that I write was a gift because afterward I was hooked on writing. I had characters constantly talking inside my head. There were heroes, heroines, murderers and tramps all vying for my attention and demanding their stories be told. How could I resist?

Soon I discovered the ugly side to writing. Submissions, or should I say, rejections. I have a thick file of rejections and the majority of these are form rejections that were based on nothing but a query letter, or a few chapters. Other writers told me rejections were a right of passage for authors and that they would make me a better writer, so I decided to treat them as a gift. This wasn’t easy because those darn things hurt.

There’s one rejection in particular that still stings. An agent requested a full manuscript from me and I was ecstatic because it was the first time I’d ever had a request for a full. A couple of months later I received her rejection and in the final paragraph she blew my world apart. She wrote, I find your characters cliché, your dialogue forced and the premise unbelievable.

Now I don’t consider myself a violent woman, but after I read that I was a tad miffed. Oh I was tempted to write her a letter. I even considered inviting her to lunch at high noon.

It’s true that, in the beginning, I didn’t exactly consider that particular rejection letter a gift. Luckily, had stupidity on my side. I re-read the agent’s letter and I thought, cliched characters, forced dialogue, unbelievable premise? I can fix that!

Around the same time I received another gift. The writing group I belonged to invited Bill Johnson to give a workshop. He’s the author of A Story Is A Promise and someone I’ve always admired. I approached him after his seminar and convinced him to critique my manuscript. I sent it off to him and a few weeks later he sent me an email reply. He listed a few points I needed to work on to strengthen my characters but in his conclusion he wrote, “I enjoyed reading your novel very much. You know how to write potent dramatic truths, and how to create a story that is a journey of feeling.”

Oh I liked him. I wanted to marry him and have his babies!

Then confusion set in. Who do I believe, the person who insulted my work, or the one who praised it? This was the same manuscript.

After careful consideration, I decided to assume that my work was average. I could handle being mediocre because I knew that I could improve my skills by honing my craft. I harassed critique partners, took more writing classes, bought more how-to books on writing, and attended more conferences. Yes, I memorized entire lectures on point of view and premise. There were times when I spent so much time reading up on how to write love scenes, that my husband told me that if I didn’t start taking those studies to a more practical level, he was going to sell my computer.

No matter how much time I spent hiding behind courses, seminars and books, in the end, I still had to confront that damn blank computer screen. I tried and tried to force my writing to fit the mold that I thought was necessary for publication.

I wrote romantic suspense but my heroes and heroines always came off sounding staged and stupid. I didn’t know how to make my characters take their tragedies seriously. Of course, more and more rejections poured in. Some, a very few, had hints as to what the problems were; the plots weren’t unique, the hero too weak, the heroine too flawed. I kept on writing, but I didn’t feel like I was getting any closer. No matter what the rejection letters said, the words that I read were: We hate you. Just stop sending us stuff, you moron.

Ouch! I wanted the editors to know that I was a real person, made of flesh, blood and cellulite! Of course it’s not their job to form an attachment to the author. Editors need to fall in love with the writing. I needed my words to evoke in them, the same level of emotion that their rejection letters evoked in me. I knew what all writers know, that if I couldn’t tug on the heartstrings, or tickle the funny bone of an editor, she would never believe I could work that magic on a reader.

Determined to create more in-depth characters that an editor would love, I read up on what some multi-published authors do. I discovered that many writers suggested that we reach inside our own lives and grasp onto the situations that are both comical and tragic and bring that level of feeling into our writing. Apparently, most people have experienced moments of extreme fear or sorrow and had those same moments twist into something laughable, yet often we don’t reach that deeply for our characters. I wanted that level of emotion in my writing, so I looked for examples in my own life.

On July 1, 1993 after 17 hours of hard labour, I gave birth to my first child. In the moments following that baby’s birth, I felt the entire rainbow of emotions. First, was overwhelming relief that that thing was finally out of my body. Then they said it’s a girl and I was elated!

Seconds later, I watched as my tiny bundle was rushed to a side table. Her blue, lifeless form was placed under warming lights and I watched in horror as my doctor worked up a sweat trying to pump air into her reluctant lungs. My heart was gripped in a fear like I’d never known before. There was a deadly silence in the delivery room and I held my own breath until the doctor was finally able to get oxygen into my little girl’s lungs, and I felt pure ecstasy when she breathed on her own. The relieved doctor walked my pink bundle toward my outstretched arms and, in gratitude, my precious little girl peed all over that good doctor. In less than a minute I’d gone from acute terror, to a fit of giggles.

Is it possible to get those extreme emotions onto the written page? Of course it is. We’ve all read books that have made us laugh and cry.

When you feel like rejection letters are aiming personal arrows at your heart, and you think that you’ll never get beyond a form letter from an editor, that is exactly when you must press your body into the chair at your computer and pour emotion onto the screen.

Personally, I’ve written some of my best stuff when filled with the anguish from a recent rejection. The trick is to pick yourself up by your bra straps and force yourself to write. Write something. Write anything. If it’s too painful for you to turn to your manuscript, then write a scene of sorrow or mirth from your own life.

In detail you could describe your most embarrassing moment. Could your heroine experience a similar moment? Have you lost someone close to you? Could your hero lose someone in a similar way? Who would you kill, if you thought you could get away with it? Write that murder scene and, of course, shred those pages afterward.

If you can bring yourself to write about the comical and heartrending moments in your own life, you can often trick your rejection-scarred muse into dipping back into your manuscript. When we look for drama inside ourselves, it inspires us to create a deeper level of feeling in our work.

After all, what good is the pain involved in receiving rejections, if you can’t use those feelings to your advantage? Rejections are insulting, demeaning and even embarrassing. It is totally unfair that a few lines from an editor or agent can whisk your hard work into the trash heap. Let it out! After you open a rejection you should, cry, pout, scream, and shout. Some people choose to get drunk. If I did that after every rejection, I would now be a long-standing member of AA instead of RWA. Do what works for you, but do it fast. Give yourself a week at the most to mourn a rejection letter.

Why only a week? Why not allow yourself to avoid writing altogether for weeks or months on end, until you feel better? Because you’ll never feel better. Even once you sell, chances are good you will need to deal with the rejection of your second, fourth or twelfth book. Yes, I’ve already researched that fact personally on your behalf.

You need to establish a pick-yourself-up and dust-yourself-off attitude now. It just doesn’t get any easier. Every week that you spend not writing, encourages you to form a habit of not writing. Every day you spend not writing, thousands of other authors are. Use your anguish and disappointment to propel emotion onto the written page as soon as possible.

As my own collection of rejections piled up, it was getting harder and harder to see them as a gift. Still, I forced myself to write through the hurt. It was not easy. The faster I wrote, the faster I was rejected and, let me tell you, I was motivated. My husband wanted me to return to work with him in his real estate office, once our youngest child started kindergarten. I was desperate. I either needed to sell, or face the prospect that I would lose precious writing time sitting behind a desk plotting my husband’s untimely demise.

Although I’d been writing with children at my feet for years, I fantasized about the freedom of writing while they were in school. I needed to at least make some progress in the direction of getting published. It was laughable that now, with four beautiful children gnawing at my ankles and nipping at my nerves, I was still trying to write serious, dramatic novels. Anxiously, I waited to hear back on three different manuscripts, one each that I’d submitted to Silhouette Intimate Moments, Harlequin Intrigue and the Bombshell line. There was nothing serious left inside me.

Then, as so often happens when we reach a point of desperation, I received another gift. This one was Nancy Warren’s workshop at the Surrey Writer’s Conference entitled, Why Is She Laughing? There I learned a phrase that would change my life forever—Chick Lit.

After the conference I returned home waiting to be rejected by those three lines but, as a lark, I began writing a novel that had a lighter tone and, to my surprise, it actually came easy. The words just seemed to fall onto the page. Someone suggested that I submit it to Red Dress Ink, even though I’d only written the first couple chapters. I did and, of course, I got a request for a full manuscript two weeks later. I panicked. Especially when the three rejections I’d been expecting arrived in the mail shortly afterward.

Fueled and riding high on the emotions of those rejections, I pumped out the balance of my novel in under a month. When the manuscript was completed, I was convinced that I’d embarrassed myself with the drivel I’d spewed onto the page. It couldn’t possibly be any good, after all, I’d written off the cuff, without second guessing myself, and without agonizing over every single word, like usual.

Then, on the morning of August 8, I got the call from Red Dress Ink saying that they wanted to buy my crap.

Nobody was more shocked than me.

After I hung up the phone from talking to Kathryn Lye, I couldn’t help but laugh. I laughed until I cried and those tears of joy sure tasted sweet. Then, as I recounted every rejection and setback along the way, I cried entirely different tears. I knew that at any given moment I could have given in and allowed those rejections to define who I am and what I would become.

Still, I will never be a firefighter or a princess, but I don’t mind so much anymore. I can always write a scene where a firefighter and a princess are doing the dance of love and, who knows, someone might even buy it.

Wendy Roberts is a member of GVC.

Articles may be reprinted in RWA® chapter newsletters, attributed to the Spotlight. Non-RWA® newsletters may not reprint articles without the permission of the authors.

Back to top

 

This page was last updated April 23, 2004.