HOMEMEMBERSPUBLISHED AUTHORSMEETINGS
EVENTSNEWSLIBRARYNEWSLETTERLINKS
 

November 2005 Spotlight Article

Plotting
by Judy Jackson

Everything in my life feels more comfortable if I have a plan. And that includes writing. Pre-planning the plot doesn’t have to feel like a straight-jacket. Some people look at a plot outline as a skeleton on which to hang their story – for me it’s more like a map. Maps don’t tie you down to traveling in only one direction; getting lost leads to many unexpected adventures.

When first writing out your plot, no matter what outline format you use, you’ll have lots of ideas for scenes of character development or story action – use the strongest or the most meaningful or the most emotional for readers.

For me, story ideas start with a character facing trouble or a difficult situation or an unusual setting. I love to brainstorm my plots, either with other writers or alone, focusing on characters or events – or both together.

If I begin with characters I wonder: Who is she? Why is she in trouble or danger? Why is she worried? Who caused the trouble or danger or worry? What will happen if she wins/loses? How will she be changed?

If I begin with events I wonder: Where is it happening? What caused the situation? What’s at risk? What type of person would be in this position or place? Who would be most out of place? The characters and the plot need to fit together; the reader has to believe that these people could possibly end up in that situation.

Then I figure out the goal for one of the two main characters – and why they can’t achieve that goal. I find out why their goal becomes a quest they can’t abandon. I ponder the one person who makes that quest difficult or impossible. Then I figure out the second person’s goal and how it conflicts with the first person’s quest. Their goals should be in opposition: In stronger stories both characters have internal and external goals – and when both goals conflict on both levels you’ll get high tension scenes.

Then I work out scenes where the two protagonists struggle to fulfill both of their goals… or not. I try to have the characters’ good qualities and flaws mirror each other which can cause each of them to act / react…which creates plot.

At this point I start stream of consciousness writing – filling 10 to 30 pages. It’s a jumble of ideas in point form, bits of dialogue, a phrase or two of setting and description. Thoughts pour out, jumbled together in little or no order, and I don’t fret about where or how they’ll fit together. This bit of writing would probably make little or no sense to anyone else.

At this point I start collecting pictures of my story’s people, settings, and totem objects.

Then I start writing another version of my story, expanding the outline and notes into partial scenes, leaving the occasional idea as a notation if I don’t know how to flesh it out or I’m not sure where, or if, it belongs. At this point my synopsis can be 50 to 60 pages long. Occasionally it’s longer.

Then I start digging deep into my characters’ goals and motivations. I search for the emotions that are driving their quests - the secret, often subconscious, reasons their heart and mind won’t allow this quest to be abandoned or ignored. I search for the real instigator – the one event or factor that set them on this path. This helps me create plot events that put them at the most emotional risk. I try to ensure that every scene, especially the story opening, shows (or hints at) their personality and purpose.

There are many different methods for digging into character motivation. I don’t use the same method for every book or even every character in one book. But I dig until I feel that spark that brings the hero and heroine alive for me.

Joan Kilby says: “Individuals behave in certain ways because of who they are. The choices they make under pressure and the consequences of their actions determine the plot. Without conflict there is no plot.”

Build every scene around an irrevocable event that changes the plot. Try to ensure that every scene advances external or internal plot, increases tension, reveals character growth or shows new aspects of character. A scene should do more than one of those. The most powerful scenes do them all.

Scenes of high and low tension determine pacing. A series of high tension scenes could be boring if they’re not mingled with slower moments where the readers and the characters can catch their breath. When plotting the scene content, consider which POV gives each scene more punch. Figure out which character has more at stake in the scene’s outcome and make them the POV character.

Alicia Rasley says: “Protagonist’s actions and reactions are the driving force of the plot, and this causes events which change him/her in some way. What are they willing to do for their goal? What are they unwilling to do?”

Each plot needs 2 - 4 major turning points. A turning point is a major event that changes the course of the plot and the protagonists must act or react. Each turning point should re-direct a character’s goals or the story action or increase a character’s risk or the scene tension

Use cause and effect in plotting. Your main character(s) should save their world or devastate it. In classic storytelling the characters’ flaws can cause their own destruction and they must learn to control that character flaw or change it. Perhaps a character’s strength can lead to their ruin. Static characters are boring; unless they change and grow the plot will be weak.

Find ways to have external events cause internal change. Then make the internal change cause new external events.

I try to create an outline that shows:

• the ‘hook’ or set-up
• their external and internal problems
• turning points
• developing subplot(s)
• the rising conflict and increasing stakes
• the crisis or black moment
• the climax
• the resolution

I mention events where the hero and heroine (and villain, if there is one) interact, decide, confront, learn, realize or recognize. Show how each event causes the next event.

And that’s why I have such a hard time writing short synopses.

For me, plot relies on character goal and motivation - and pacing is part of plot and influenced by character.

If I have a map I don’t fret about where the story is going. If I have a plan for the book, I experience more joy in the writing and the words.

Plotting Resources

The following list is not comprehensive by any means. Lots of information is available in books and on the net. Teresa Eckford provided some of the websites listed below.

WEBSITES:

The RWA® website www.rwanational.org has archived many RWR articles at and the following can be found under Members Only / craft / plotting:

Patrice Cassedy and Stuart Voytilla
JOURNEYS OF THE HEART - USING MYTHIC STRUCTURE TO
CREATE BETTER ROMANCES

Susan Wiggs
RIPPED FROM THE HEADLINES: HOW REAL LIFE CAN INFORM
YOUR STORY

Irene Goodman
FOURTEEN SURE-FIRE ROMANCE PLOTS

Debra Dixon and Jill Marie Landis
THE HERO’S JOURNEY—A ROAD MAP

Libby Sternberg
PROLOGUES AND EPILOGUES: LITERARY BOOKENDS

Eloisa James
PLOTTING IN THE WILD

Alicia Rasley has many excellent writing articles on her website, some on plotting:

CHARACTER <-> PLOT COHERENCE

STARTING SMALL AND BUILDING PLOT

THE THREE ACTS: MAJOR TURNING POINTS

THIRTEEN PRIME PLOT PRINCIPLES

PLOTTING WITHOUT FEARS

Adrianne Lee
PLOTTING CONFLICT: (includes internal and external conflict plot plan) “Conflict makes story”

Sarah Smith
HOW TO PLOT WHEN YOU CAN’T

Carolyn Jewel
for writers / craft / miscellaneous important stuff / plotting
PLOT - WHAT IS IT AND HOW DO I GET ONE?

Karleen Bradford
OUTLINES: THINK OF A SKELETON, NOT A CAGE
PLOTTING THE STORY

Lee Masterson
PLOTTING YOUR NOVEL

JoAnn Ross
EXTERNAL VS INTERNAL CONFLICT

Stella Cameron
PLOTTING YOUR NOVEL

Tina St John
PLOT: TURNING IDEAS INTO BOOKS

Lisa Gardner
PLOTTING THE NOVEL: OTHERWISE KNOWN AS THE REAL REASON WRITERS ARE NEUROTIC

Deborah Hale
writing tips/archived articles in left column
FORGING PLOT CHAINS
PROBLEM/SOLUTION CHAINS: A SOLUTION FOR PLOTTING
PROBLEMS

Karen Harbaugh
PLOTTING AND CHARACTERIZATION WITH ARCHETYPES AND FAIRY TALES

Joan Kilby
TRULY, MADLY, DEEPLY: ADDING DEPTH AND COMPLEXITY TO YOUR STORY THROUGH CHARACTER AND PLOT

BOOKS:

Dwight V. Swain
TECHNIQUES OF THE SELLING WRITER

Christopher Vogler
THE WRITER’S JOURNEY: MYTHIC STRUCTURE FOR STORYTELLERS AND SCREENWRITERS

Debra Dixon
GMC: GOAL, MOTIVATION AND CONFLICT

Pam McCutcheon and Michael Waite
THE WRITER’S BRAINSTORMING KIT: THINKING IN NEW DIRECTIONS

Vanessa Grant
WRITING ROMANCE
Self Counsel Press

Nancy Kress
BEGINNINGS, MIDDLES & ENDS
Writers Digest Books

Alicia Rasley
THE STORY WITHIN GUIDEBOOK
Interactive guidebook to plotting popular fiction

Karen S. Wiesner
FIRST DRAFT IN 30 DAYS

Judy Jackson is a member of RWA®-Greater Vancouver Chapter.

Articles may be reprinted in RWA® chapter newsletters, attributed to the Spotlight. Non-RWA® newsletters may not reprint articles without the permission of the authors.

Back to top

 

This page was last updated February 11, 2006.